“Defense experts aren’t here for the truth. They’re here for the paycheck. Show the jury that and you can overcome them.” – Tom Crosley
Welcome to Winning The TBI Case hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen each week as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.
Overcome “Junk Science” to Gain Jury Trust
Defense lawyers do not like TBI cases. They are complicated. They are potentially permanent. They can be expensive. When they are unable to argue the injury away, they turn to hired gun experts wielding junk science. In this episode, Tom breaks down the three main types of defense experts every litigator will face and reveals the systematic approach to dismantling their credibility on cross-examination. Tom shares real trial examples of exposing confirmation bias, flipping defense buzzwords against them, and why following the money trail is your most powerful weapon against these paid opinion witnesses.
Key Takeaways
- Cross-examination starts in discovery
- The three-step approach to destroying defense neuropsychologists
- How to shut down the “no objective evidence” argument
- Taking apart the biomechanics expert’s claims
- Follow the money trail to expose the defense’s hired guns
Winning the TBI Case — Episode 8: How to Tear Apart the Defense’s Junk Science Experts
Crosley Law | Aired: September 23, 2025 | Runtime: 23:27 | Speakers: Narrator, Tom Crosley
[0:00] Tom Crosley: Cross-examining defense junk science witnesses is an art form, and it varies from one to the next based on what the track record of that witness is, how much witness testimony you can get from other cases, what articles you have, et cetera.
[0:15] Narrator: TBI cases can feel like navigating uncharted territory. Your client’s injury is real, but proving it, that’s where the real challenge begins. If you’ve ever felt like you’re missing crucial pieces of the puzzle, you’re in the right place. Welcome to Winning the TBI Case, where Tom Crosley shares the insights he’s gained from over 60 injury trials. Not just the victories, but the lessons learned along the way that make all the difference. This is practical wisdom from someone who’s been in your shoes and found a path forward. Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling. In this episode, Tom explains how defense lawyers try to dismiss your client’s injury with what could be considered junk science. Let’s join Tom as he walks us through his approach to exposing these paid opinion witnesses from setting traps in discovery to following the money trail.
[1:17] Tom Crosley: Welcome back to Winning the TBI Case. I’m Tom Crosley, and today we’re gonna be talking about one of the most satisfying moments in any TBI trial, tearing apart the defense’s so-called experts on cross-examination. Now, let’s be honest. The defense doesn’t like brain injury cases. They’d much rather be arguing about soft tissue damage, injuries that heal, injuries that fit neatly into a box. But TBIs, they’re complicated. They’re potentially permanent. They’re expensive. Who knows what a jury will do? You can’t use past medical expenses as a barometer of exposure in a TBI case. Remember that old adage from the car wreck soft tissue injury case that the value of the case is three times the medical bills? Well, throw that out the window for a TBI case because the value of a TBI case might bear no relation whatsoever to medical bills. I’ve had cases with $30,000 in past medical bills and eight-figure verdicts because it’s not about what the medical bills are. There’s not a lot medical science can do to treat most TBIs. The damage is done, and it can’t be reversed.
[2:32] Tom Crosley: Brain cells are dead. They’re not coming back. You can’t heal them. So defense lawyers don’t like these cases. Insurance companies don’t know how to evaluate them, and often the defense will be, “Well, let’s say that it’s not a brain injury, that this is probably related to something else. It’s psychiatric. It’s preexisting. It’s depression.” If the plaintiff ever had depression in their life, God forbid, then whatever problems they’re having after the brain injury must be related to that depression they had when they got divorced 15 years ago. That’s the defense. That is literally the defense in the last case I tried. So they’re gonna look for something else in that person’s life and try to pin the tail on that donkey and not on the TBI. So what do defense lawyers do to defend these cases? They hire experts who minimize, deny, or flat out dismiss your client’s injury, and their go-to strategy often is rooted in some kind of junk science. They’ll bring in usually three types of experts on the damage side of a case, maybe more if you get into life care plans. But number one, they’ll bring in a neuropsychologist who will cherry-pick test results to claim that your client is fine, that they’re behaving within normal limits.
[3:54] Tom Crosley: They’ll bring in a radiologist with great credentials who’ll say, “This MRI looks normal to me.” And that’s the tough thing about MRIs. It’s like those Rorschach inkblot tests where, you know, you look at it, and one person looks at the inkblot and might see a butterfly, and the next person looks at the inkblot and might see a samurai. That’s what I tell people that cross-examining a radiologist is like. The radiologist will put an image up on a screen and say, “Yep, look at this. That tells me XYZ.” You can’t really say, “No, it doesn’t. I see something different.” I mean, we can’t… That’s the deep end. We can’t get in the deep end of the pool with that radiologist, so what do we do about it? I’ll tell you in a little bit what we do about it, and I’m gonna devote an entire episode to neuroradiology and how to get the best of the defense on these cases. So this is the overview part. The third part that we often see in these cases is that the defense will hire a biomechanical expert to say, “Oh, there wasn’t enough force in this crash to cause a TBI. The amount of force was, you know, X G-forces, and that’s like sneezing or stepping off a curb. That can’t cause a brain injury.” So those are the three that we normally face in these cases, and if you don’t know how to handle these witnesses, your case can fall apart fast because it’s our burden of proof.
[5:15] Tom Crosley: We’re the plaintiff. We’ve got to get it to the finish line, and if there’s doubt in the jury’s mind, that doubt is probably gonna get resolved against your client. If you walk into a cross-examination with these witnesses with a game plan, there is no greater feeling than watching a so-called expert squirm when you expose their bad science in front of a jury. Number one, cross-examination starts in discovery. We’ve got to set the trap early. If you wait until trial to start dismantling the defense’s experts, you’re probably too late. Starting in discovery, we’ve got to depose them and lock them into definitive statements. We’ve got to gather their past testimony from as many cases as we can to catch inconsistencies or, more likely, consistencies. What do I mean by that? I’m doing one in a week or two where I’ve got 27 different expert reports from this well-known defense doctor. In 27 different cases, all 27 cases, he reaches the same conclusion that the plaintiff isn’t really hurt and all the problems relate to stressors in that person’s life that have nothing to do with the injury or the brain damage. It sounds pretty good when you read the one report, but when you find out that this is his go-to canned defense report that he does in every case, it rings a little hollow, doesn’t it?
[6:32] Tom Crosley: I had another case where the defense expert, he was a neuropsychologist, how he was so great that the NFL hired him to evaluate all these retired NFL players under the disability policy program, because if they had a playing related cognitive brain injury, they would be eligible for compensation. Well, it sounded very impressive and the jury seemed impressed by him until I got him on cross-examination and was able to get him to admit, because I’d done my homework, that of the 50 NFL players that he had evaluated for playing related brain injury, he found exactly zero of them had a playing related brain injury. And once the jury heard that, they no longer trusted him as a truth teller and instead looked at him like the hired gun he was, who did almost all of his work for the defense. And typically these kind of witnesses are doing 95% of the work for the defense. So that means we’ve got to dig into who’s paying them and how often they testify for the defense. So you don’t go into trial hoping to catch them. You go in knowing exactly where their weak spots are and you hit them with those weak spots.
[7:52] Tom Crosley: Let’s talk about the defense neuropsychologist. It’s usually the number one weapon of the defense. Their entire job is to argue that your client isn’t really injured or that if they are, the problems are caused by something else. They’ll use phrases like, “The plaintiff performed within normal limits on my testing of him or her.” They’ll use phrases like, “There’s no objective evidence of brain injury,” or in some jurisdictions they’re not allowed to talk about brain injury, so they’ll say, “There’s no objective evidence that the plaintiff has any deficits attributable to a brain injury.” They’ll say things like, “Any cognitive issues they have are more likely due to their preexisting depression or anxiety,” or fill in the blank, some other preexisting thing. So step one, expose their confirmation bias. Most defense neuropsychologists aren’t treating doctors. They’re hired guns. They spend in the three-year life of a case a few hours testing your client, but they don’t treat them. They don’t follow up. They don’t care about them beyond the case. So I like to ask, “In your current practice, doctor, how many TBI patients do you personally treat on an ongoing basis? How often?” The answer is almost always they don’t.
[9:08] Tom Crosley: Next, “You’re not the plaintiff’s doctor, correct? You’ve only seen them once. You have no obligation to see them again. You’ve got no doctor-patient relationship. You could be wrong but not liable for malpractice. In your practice, do you ever testify on behalf of plaintiffs who have had brain injury?” I mean, you’ve got to know the answer to that question before you ask it, but most of the time the answer is going to be no. And so most of these people end up being career defense witnesses. They’ll testify 95% of the time for the insurance companies and jurors need to know that so they can judge whether the testimony they’re hearing is authentic and truly curated for this case based on the evidence or whether it’s part of a spiel that this defense witness gives in every case no matter what the facts are.
[9:56] Narrator: If you’re finding value in today’s episode, here’s how you can take your TBI practice to the next level. Subscribe to our newsletter at crosleylaw.com/podcast for exclusive case studies, resources, and trial strategies you won’t hear anywhere else. That’s crosleylaw.com/podcast or click the link in the show notes below. Don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them.
[10:29] Tom Crosley: Next, I like to lock the defense witnesses into their favorite buzzwords and then try to flip the script on them. So let me tell you what I mean by that. Defense neuropsychologists love saying things like, “Well, based on my testing, the plaintiff performed within normal limits.” That means she’s doing just fine. Here’s how I like to turn that against them. “You know, doctor, you said the plaintiff’s cognitive test scores were within normal limits. Can you define normal limits?” And they’ll say something like, “Well, it means their performance falls within the expected range for their age and education.” And then I’ll say something like, “Well, but normal limits, that includes everyone from someone in peak cognitive health to someone just barely scraping by, right?” “Well, yeah.” “If we look in this room with the 15 or 20 people in this room right now, we’re probably all within normal limits, right?” “Well, I mean, probably.” “So within normal limits, that doesn’t mean that they’re functioning at their pre-injury level, does it?” And if they’re honest, they have to admit no. I mean, you could take somebody with Einstein’s IQ and damage their brain in a significant way to not make them Einstein anymore, but they could still be theoretically within normal limits.
[11:47] Tom Crosley: I mean, somebody with a significantly below average IQ is still, quote, within normal limits. So we need to understand how this testing works. We need to understand bell curves. We need to understand standard deviations and we need to figure out how to tell it to a jury. Medical records, if done right, can be a huge help for us here. And so then my question to that expert is, “Well, in fact, they could have lost significant cognitive ability and still be considered normal, right, sir, based on these tests?” If they’re being truthful, they have to answer, “Correct. Technically, yes.” That’s an answer I got once. It was technically yes. So here’s the idea. Let’s try to get the jury to see through this smokescreen that this is really just a hired gun brought in to assassinate this issue in the case and expose it for what it is. Next, let’s talk about another technique for trying to combat defense experts. It’s called shutting down the, quote, no objective evidence, close quote, argument. It’s a classic defense move. They argue that there’s no objective evidence of a brain injury because traditional MRIs don’t show anything. And to the extent you have some advanced neuroimaging that shows something, they’ll say, “Well, that’s not generally accepted.
[13:03] Tom Crosley: We don’t use that in clinical practice. That’s not good for diagnosing an injury in an individual case. That’s used more for research studies. You shouldn’t rely on it,” et cetera. And that’s why you need your own neuroradiologist. If the other side has a radiologist, I mean, frankly, you should always have your own radiologist. Sometimes I’ve gotten to try cases where I had the neuroradiologist and the defense didn’t, and I love it when that happens because when my guy looks at the Rorschach blot, he gets to say it shows whatever it shows, whatever he wants it to say. No one can refute it. When the other guy comes in and looks at the same scan and says, “No, that’s not what it says,” then I’ve got a real fight on my hands, and that’s a hard expert to cross. So what do we do there? We need our neuroradiologists to understand the advanced imaging and do a remarkably good show and tell, one that is so good that there is little room for doubt by the time the defense guy comes in a week and a half later. And it becomes very specific to who that radiologist is. You know, are they regularly interpreting DTI scans? I’ve had plenty of them. In one case, I had one guy who said, “No, I don’t use DTI in my practice because, you know, we just don’t use it on patients.” I’m like, “Then who are you to say that the DTI is inaccurate?” I mean, so we got to dig into the weeds a little bit.
[14:25] Tom Crosley: I’m usually using peer-reviewed studies, and there’s so much medical literature out there, especially after two thousand and eight, in what I call the modern era of neuroscience, that we can find articles that support whatever position we are looking to take. We can find multiple articles usually. And so if you have laid the groundwork right with your other experts and gotten these articles identified as reliable authority and your jurisdiction allows you to use them, you can then cross-examine defense experts with the same thing. So by using these peer-reviewed scientific articles that support DTI or that support various findings that are consistent with your case, you can either make the expert admit that they’re wrong or that they look completely uninformed or third, and you can easily do this third one, show that even though their opinion might be different, the bulk of this medical science and research coming out over the last several years is consistent with the plaintiff’s side of the case. That’s usually my fallback cross-examination. The medical research is on my side. The defense expert is in the minority. All right. Now let’s talk about the biomechanical expert and how to expose that person as a fraud.
[15:45] Tom Crosley: So when the biomechanical engineer hired by the defense claims there wasn’t enough force in this crash to cause a TBI, there’s a bunch of things we can do here. Books have been written on this subject. Remember, these guys are not medical doctors. They sit at a desk. They plug numbers into a computer. They spit out a fancy-looking force calculation that makes it sound like your client couldn’t possibly be hurt. So we establish, “Hey, doctor, you’re not a medical doctor, correct? You’ve never diagnosed a brain injury, correct? You’ve never treated a single patient for TBI, have you? So when you say this crash couldn’t have caused a brain injury, isn’t that a clinical decision? Isn’t it up to treating physicians to tell us whether something can or was caused by a certain event? Don’t we have…” I mean, there’s great rebuttal experts we can sometimes use, epidemiologists, national automotive sampling, statistical databases where we can look at small forces are equated with significant brain injuries. It’s just a matter of population and statistics. If you take a bell curve of the entire human population and all the accidents that have ever been gathered into a database, you’ll find some on the very low end of the spectrum that result in death even. So you can’t categorically say that a small amount of force cannot cause an injury.
[17:06] Tom Crosley: So now let’s talk about exposing the biomechanical expert as a fraud. We’ve got to take apart the biomechanical engineer who claims there wasn’t enough force in the crash to cause a TBI. These guys are not medical doctors. I’ve had them say, “Oh, this force from this was like plopping into a chair or stepping off a curb or sneezing.” It’s kind of ridiculous because you’ve got to dive into the studies from which they reach these conclusions, and typically I’m trying to prevent these experts from espousing these opinions in the first place through motions to strike or limit their testimony under Daubert, the case law that allows a judge to be the gatekeeper of what an expert can say and rule out junk science before a jury ever hears it. But if a jury does get to hear the junk science, then it’s helpful to have your own expert explain why it was junk science. That means hiring your own biomechanical expert to either come back in rebuttal or to pre-rebut these notions. And the rebuttal is usually something like, “Hey, the test that he’s relying on to show that there’s not enough force was done on two hundred helmeted high school football players.” Your client was a 60-year-old woman who didn’t have a helmet on.
[18:26] Tom Crosley: It’s like a comparison of apples and oranges. Or maybe some of the other studies they rely on are people who volunteered for low-speed crashes. And there’s a big difference between, you know, a 30-year-old engineer who volunteers to be a test subject in a low-speed crash and them putting measuring devices on him to figure out what his movement of his skull is during the crash. It’s a big difference between that guy and your client, who might be a frail woman, it might be an older person, it might be someone who was looking off to the side. But in any event, it was almost always somebody who was blindsided completely unexpectedly. Very rarely do we have the plaintiff sitting in the car saying, “Okay, I’m gonna get hit soon, and I know when it’s… Here it comes. I’m gonna brace myself for it.” And so the point we’re going to make is that the examples they use to reach their flimsy conclusions are manufactured for them to reach these very flimsy conclusions. They’re not a result of real-world accidents. We’re gonna establish that they’re not medical doctors, they don’t diagnose brain injuries, that they don’t treat patients for TBI, and that you cannot very well say after the fact that someone wasn’t injured.
[19:42] Tom Crosley: Here’s an example that I’ve often used, and I think I got it from Dr. Michael Freeman. You can’t say to the widow of someone who died in a plane crash, “Hey, most people don’t die in plane crashes, therefore your husband didn’t die in a plane crash.” Because that exposes the logical fallacy that’s at the heart of all these biomechanical defense witnesses, and it is this. They say, “Most people aren’t hurt in a force of this magnitude, therefore the plaintiff probably wasn’t hurt.” That’s a fallacy. It’s like saying that if a stuntman falls down the stairs in a movie and gets up and keeps chasing the bad guy, that when your client fell down the stairs and had a brain injury, that she should have been able to get up and keep chasing the bad guy. In other words, because it happened to one person in a simulated experiment designed for that purpose, you can’t extrapolate from that that the outcome would be the same for every person in the human population. There’s just way too many variables, and so that’s usually where we’re attacking them. The biggest, most effective way for all of these witnesses in cross is following the money. So medical literature or reliable authority, number one, and following the money, number two.
[21:02] Tom Crosley: I always try to expose how much these witnesses are getting paid, and sometimes it’s obscene amounts of money. How much are you charging for your testimony today? How many times have you testified for the defense in the last five years? Let’s do some math. Sometimes I’ll call him the five-million-dollar man or whatever that number is. Every now and then, you know, it’s argumentative, but every now and then I might ask the question of, “Well, if I were to pay you $100,000, would you say that he was injured?” I’ll draw an objection to that question almost every time, but the point that I’ve made is that the jury understands greed, and the moment they see the expert is just a hired gun, the goal is they quit believing what the expert will say. So here’s how I’m gonna bring it all together. Cross-examining defense junk science witnesses is an art form, and it varies from one to the next based on what the track record of that witness is, how much witness testimony you can get from other cases, what articles you have, et cetera. But you’re gonna start in discovery and trap them early. You’re gonna expose their bias that they’re paid to say your client isn’t hurt. You’re gonna try to use their own words against them. Things like normal limits are gonna become a weakness. You’re gonna shut down the no objective evidence claim by bringing in real science.
[22:20] Tom Crosley: You’re gonna destroy the biomechanical engineer to remind the jury that they’re not doctors, that they’re relying on studies that are apples and oranges comparison. And hopefully, you’re gonna have your own rebuttal biomechanical engineer, and you’re gonna follow the money, because nothing kills credibility faster than a hired gun in the hip pocket of the defense lawyer. So remember, defense experts aren’t here for the truth. They’re here for the paycheck. Show the jury that, and you can overcome them. Thank you. This is Tom Crosley with Winning the TBI Case.
[22:59] Narrator: If today’s episode helped you see your current case in a new light, share it with a colleague who’s facing the same challenges in a case. Subscribe wherever you get your podcasts and join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. This has been Winning the TBI Case: Strategy, Science, and Storytelling with Tom Crosley.
Subscribe and Stay Connected
Are you ready to take your TBI practice to the next level? Subscribe to our Winning The TBI Case newsletter at www.crosleylaw.com/podcast for exclusive case studies, resources, and trial strategies you won’t hear anywhere else.
Join our community of trial lawyers who refuse to settle for average results. Subscribe to Winning The TBI Case on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube or wherever you get your podcasts. And remember, don’t just listen to the strategies, implement them!
