Inside an $8.1 Million TBI Verdict with Scott Blair

Written by

|

Share on social:

“ The TBI alters the organic chemistry, the physical structure of the brain to the point where our personalities then get altered. Our spirit knows who we are. But you can’t get that person back… and I think jurors get that.” – Scott Blair

Welcome to Winning The TBI Case, hosted by trial lawyer Tom Crosley. Listen as Tom provides practical, powerful guidance for litigating traumatic brain injury cases. This podcast is meant for litigation attorneys who are ready to explore the essentials of TBI cases to confidently represent clients who have suffered traumatic brain injuries.

What’s In This Episode:

Scott Blair shares how he built and tried a complex TBI case that resulted in an $8.1 million verdict.
He explains the role of advanced neuroimaging, expert strategy, and objective evidence in overcoming common defense arguments. Most importantly, he provides practical guidance on how trial lawyers can strengthen their cases by understanding the medicine, telling the client’s story, and preparing for trial from day one.

Winning Complex TBI Cases

In this episode, Tom is joined by Scott Blair, founder of Brain Injury Law of Seattle, to break down the strategy behind a recent $8.1 million traumatic brain injury verdict. Scott shares how he approaches complex cases, from digging deep into the medicine to building objective evidence that makes it difficult for the defense to deny brain injury.

This conversation goes beyond theory. Scott walks through the real decisions that shaped the case, including expert selection, advanced neuroimaging, trial strategy, and how to handle common defense tactics in high-functioning TBI clients.

Key Insights for Trial Lawyers

  • Dive deep into the medicine: The strongest TBI cases are built by lawyers who understand the underlying medical science and work closely with the right experts.
  • Objective evidence changes the game: Advanced imaging, sleep studies, and vestibular testing can create converging proof that is difficult for the defense to dismiss.
  • High-functioning clients require a different strategy: Clients who continue working after injury often face skepticism. Demonstrating how their capacity has changed is critical.
  • Tell the employer early: Encouraging clients to disclose their brain injury can lead to documentation and accommodations that strengthen their case.
  • Neutralize defense narratives early: Address issues like travel photos or work performance before the defense raises them to reduce their impact at trial.
  • Use real-world functioning, not just testing: Speech-language pathology and real-world observations can be more persuasive than traditional neuropsychological testing alone.
  • Before and after witnesses are critical: Family members, especially spouses, provide powerful testimony about how the client has changed after the injury.
  • Visual evidence matters: Jurors respond strongly to clear visual representations of brain injury, especially when complex science is involved.

This episode is for trial lawyers who want to take their TBI cases to the next level. If you’re handling complex or high-value cases, Scott Blair’s approach offers a practical roadmap for building stronger evidence, overcoming defense strategies, and presenting a compelling case at trial.

Subscribe and Stay Connected