“Uber and Lyft represent a trend for how people will get around in the future,” explains San Antonio City Councilman Rey Saldaña. The question is, will we ever get to that future? With protests, committee meetings, and a constantly shifting economic and legislative landscape all related to ridesharing companies operating in San Antonio, the future Saldaña is talking about seems further and further away.
Because ridesharing companies are a relatively new (and extremely popular) addition to the market, many unexpected questions have arisen about their operation: should these companies be regulated in the same way as taxi companies? Is it even fair to regulate ridesharing services in the same way as taxi companies? Should the city require rideshare drivers to have the same qualifications as taxi drivers? Will consumers have sufficient insurance coverage while using a rideshare service? This list of questions and concerns seems to only be getting longer, which is perhaps why San Antonio’s Public Safety Committee recently postponed making a decision about allowing Lyft and Uber to operate in the city until November.
Amongst all the controversy, a few things are clear. First of all, it is currently illegal for Lyft and Uber to be operating in the city of San Antonio. In fact, police have been ticketing Lyft and Uber drivers as well as towing and impounding their vehicles. However, it appears as though these services are still active in the city.
It’s also clear that consumers have very good insurance coverage if they are taking advantage of these services (which are, just to reiterate, illegal in San Antonio). For example, both Lyft and Uber provide insurance coverage up to one million dollars (in addition to the driver’s own insurance policy) that begins the moment a passenger steps into a ridesharing vehicle. It has been widely publicized that this amount is, in fact, almost 18 times higher than the coverage amount required for taxis in San Antonio, which is a completely different issue altogether (and one that we discussed in depth in an earlier post).
Although the insurance coverage involving paying customers is very transparent, the biggest and most controversial questions about ridesharing companies involve insurance coverage for the drivers when they’re off duty or when they’re driving to or from a job. There have been numerous cases recently where drivers have gotten involved in a crash while driving around waiting for a new fare or while driving home from a fare. Earlier this year, for example, an Uber driver struck a family in a crosswalk causing severe injuries to the mother and 4-year-old son while fatally injuring her 6-year-old daughter. At the time, it appears as though he did not have an active fare; however, the driver claimed that he was only in the city because he was hoping to get a few rides.
This is exactly where some of the gray areas involved with ridesharing insurance coverage arise. As NPR has reported, “Uber uses social media to match drivers and passengers. The company also asks drivers to hang out on the streets — especially during peak times like New Year’s Eve — so they can respond to new requests quickly. Drivers even get rated by their response time.” Despite wanting drivers in opportune locations at peak times, Uber and Lyft, unlike taxi companies, do not provide any coverage unless a driver has an active fare.
Uber and Lyft also do not provide any coverage for drivers returning from a job, so if a driver’s only purpose for being on the road is to complete a fare, they do not receive coverage for their entire trip. Thus, if they get in an accident, even though it was essentially during a time that they were performing their job because they would not have been on the road otherwise, their personal insurance is the only one covering them, much to the chagrin of their insurance company.
The blurred line between what counts as personal and professional driving as well as the use of what basically amounts to conditional commercial insurance policies leaves drivers stuck in the middle of insurer/company/insurer battles: The driver’s insurance doesn’t want to pay claims that directly result from commercial (and thus riskier) activities, ridesharing companies don’t want to pay for full commercial insurance to cover their drivers at all times, and the ridesharing service’s insurers don’t want to pay claims for drivers that aren’t actually “on the job.”
But it’s not just ridesharing drivers who are going to suffer from this coverage problem. Down the road, the aggregate effect of increased “off duty” claims being made and paid by drivers’ insurance companies will mean higher premiums for all drivers, especially if the popularity and use of these ridesharing services continues to grow.
Ultimately, a future with ridesharing as a potential or even primary form of transportation is uncertain. Obviously, the issues related to driver coverage need to be clarified to keep our roads as safe as possible. In the meantime, we can only wait and see what decision City Council will make based on the information they gather between now and November. We should also do our best to stay informed about this issue and use our best judgment as we make decisions about our transportation needs.
Should you be involved in a car accident of any kind, contact Crosley Law Firm right away. We stay up to date on all of the most recent news, regulations, and laws, and our attorneys have years of experience dealing with auto accident claims in Texas. You can reach us by phone at (877) 535-4529 or you can submit your information on our website for an absolutely free case review.
 Saldaña, R. (2014, September 1). Embrace Uber and Lyft to signal SA is for millenial. mySA: San Antonio’s Home Page. Retrieved from http://m.mysanantonio.com/opinion/commentary/article/Embrace-Uber-and-Lyft-to-signal-SA-is-for-5726705.php
 Shahani, A. (2014, February 2). Should Uber be responsible for driver recklessness? NPR: All Tech Considered. Retrieved from http://www.npr.org/blogs/alltechconsidered/2014/02/02/270359642/is-uber-responible-for-driver-recklessness
Related ArticlesView All Blog Articles
Six Months of Crosley CaresJul 02, 2019
With the start of the 2019 New Year, Crosley Law proudly launched the community service branch of our law firm, officially founding Crosley Cares. The brainchild of our Director of Happiness Ruthie Foultz, Crosley Cares was originally a client advocacy service offered because she recognized our clients needed support navigating the often-overwhelming processes involved in […]
Most Interesting Dan in the WorldApr 18, 2019
If you were a newly minted attorney in the late ’90s, chances are your prominent office décor featured wall-to-wall boxes of discovery and a splash of color courtesy of your PC’s tropical island wallpaper. It might have been a similar setting for Daniel M. Pacheco had he continued to forge 60-hour work weeks at a […]
Spring Break Notoriously Dangerous TimeMar 12, 2019
Mid-March means thousands will be traveling along Texas roads to visit popular spring break destinations like Port Aransas and South Padre Island. For families, a trip to the beach is innocent fun, but for many teenagers and young adults immersed in binge drinking culture, spring break can be a dangerous and deadly time. In 2018 […]
A Low-Key Valentine’s DayFeb 11, 2019
The consensus around the office is in: whether you’re single, a honeymooner, or celebrating your 50th wedding anniversary, Valentine’s Day can be anything but romantic. The only thing more stressful than fighting the crowds for overpriced flowers and a marked-up dinner is forgetting to make a dinner reservation and scrambling at the last minute to […]
Were You Injured by 3M Combat Earplugs?Feb 08, 2019
Servicemembers assume their standard-issue equipment is safe to use and meets the Armed Forces’ exacting requirements. Unfortunately, 3M may have violated service members’ trust when it sold combat earplugs to the Armed Forces. While the company paid a $9.1 million settlement to the government, thousands of veterans and servicemembers are still struggling with hearing loss […]
Let’s Rodeo, San Antonio!Feb 06, 2019
The San Antonio Stock Show & Rodeo is one of the best ways to kick off the new year in South Texas! Annually attracting more than 2 million people over a three week schedule, this year’s events promise to bring an even bigger crowd. The 2019 rodeo is packed with one-of-a-kind entertainment; from a petting […]
January Health and Fitness Around San AntonioJan 25, 2019
January is the best month to revive your health and fitness regimens. Even though it’s cold, we asked around the office to find out what our firm is doing to sweat it out in January and lose those holiday pounds. Our Team’s Best Suggestions for Fat Burning and Clean Eating Managing partner Tom Crosley enjoys […]
The Largest Martin Luther King Jr. March in the CountryJan 18, 2019
On January 21, 2019, an anticipated 300,000-plus San Antonio and South Texas residents will take to the streets and march in solidarity with the late civil rights leader Martin Luther King Jr. The annual march, which takes place every year on San Antonio’s East Side, holds the record for the largest MLK Day march in […]
Albion Zogaj: Crosley Law’s 2018 Local Scholarship WinnerAug 10, 2018
We’re excited to announce Crosley Law’s 2018 Local Scholarship recipient: Albion Zogaj. Albion graduated from Health Careers High School in San Antonio. His powerful essay on distracted driving and his academic credentials contributed to his nomination and selection. Crosley Law’s Scholarship Program Empowers San Antonio Students As part of our commitment to San Antonio, Crosley […]
Crosley Law Furthers Commitment to Excellence at AAJ ConventionJul 27, 2018
Over the years, personal injury litigation has become more and more complex. It requires working closely with expert witnesses, developing complicated legal theories, conducting detailed and careful investigations, using cutting-edge technology, and much more. As part of our ongoing commitment to providing outstanding service to our clients, the Crosley Law team sent nearly all of […]
Do you or a family member
need legal advice?
Crosley Law Firm, PC is a professional corporation of trial lawyers focused on representing individuals and families who have suffered serious personal injuries or wrongful death. If you’ve been injured, fill out the form for a free consultation, or call 210-LAW-3000.