Big personal injury firms like to talk about their biggest wins. Weāve certainly had many of our own, obtaining seven-ā figure results in more than 100 cases.
But that doesnāt mean every personal injury case is worth $1Ā million or more. At CrosleyĀ Law, our average personal injury case settles for around $250,000.
100+
cases with seven-ā figure results
$250,000
our average personal injury case settles for around
For some additional context, the Insurance Information Institute reports that the average bodily injury liability claim for private passenger auto insurance was $28,278 in 2024. While this snapshot is useful as an insurance industry benchmark for personal injury car crashes, itās not the same thing as measuring the average settlement for personal injury lawsuits as a wholeāand it certainly doesnāt predict what any individual case is worth.
CrosleyĀ Lawās cases also tend to be very different from typical insurance claims. We regularly handle traumatic brain injuries, serious spinal injuries, commercial vehicle crashes, wrongful death claims, and other cases involving significant long-term damages.
So what separates a million-dollar personal injury case from one worth less? There is no single answer, but weāll review some of our settlement examples and discuss some of the factors that can apply to bigger cases.
Settlement and verdict examples
Million-dollar personal injury settlement and verdict examples from CrosleyĀ Law
The following cases are only a selection of CrosleyĀ Lawās seven-ā figure results. They involve very different accidents, injuries, and situations.
Please note that million-dollar personal injury examples such as these do not guarantee future results.
Brain injuryĀ ā
Wrongful deathĀ ā
Brain injuryĀ ā
Brain injuryĀ ā
Brain injuryĀ ā
Wrongful deathĀ ā
AmputationĀ ā
Truck crashĀ ā
Truck crashĀ ā
Motorcycle crashĀ ā
Truck crashĀ ā
Wrongful deathĀ ā
Neck injuryĀ ā
Settlement Ā· Brain injury
$30
million
Child suffers a catastrophic brain injury
CrosleyĀ Law represented the family of a young girl who suffered a devastating brain injury after falling through a defective apartment window.
Our investigation revealed that windows at the complex could open unexpectedly when unlatched and that apartment personnel had failed to follow their own safety procedures when inspecting them.
This case involved a severely injured child whose medical needs and limitations would extend far into the future. CrosleyĀ Law obtained a $30Ā million settlement for her family.
Jury verdict Ā· Wrongful death
$28Ā million
Drunk driver kills husband and critically injures wife
Ed and his wife, Aleshia, were outside their Northeast Bexar County home working on their car when an intoxicated pickup driver veered off the road and struck them.
Read the full story
Ed was pinned between the vehicles and killed. Aleshia suffered critical injuries, including a fractured neck. Their nine-year-old daughter heard the crash and ran outside afterward, adding another devastating layer to the familyās loss.
CrosleyĀ Lawās investigation uncovered evidence that the driver had been drinking beer throughout the day and became distracted after dropping a lit cigarette on the floor of his truck. He took his eyes off the roadway while trying to retrieve it and lost control. The driver later pleaded no contest to drunk-driving charges and received a prison sentence.
When settlement negotiations failed, the case went before a jury. CrosleyĀ Law presented expert testimony about the crash, the injuries, and the losses suffered by Edās family. The jury ultimately returned a $28Ā million verdict.
Settlement Ā· Brain injury
$20Ā million
Young bicyclist suffers catastrophic brain injury after delivery truck crash
Ramse was struck by a delivery truck as he rode his bicycle along a sidewalk on San Antonioās Military Drive.
Read the full story
The delivery driver had just finished a stop and was pulling out of a parking lot. Instead of stopping and making sure the sidewalk was clear, the driver accelerated toward an opening in traffic while looking to the left. Ramse was approaching from the right.
The truck struck him at nearly 10 mph and knocked him to the ground. Ramse suffered a skull fracture, massive intracranial bleeding, and severe brain swelling. Doctors performed an emergency craniectomy to relieve pressure on his brain, and he remained in a medically induced coma for about a month.
Although Ramse survived, his life changed dramatically. He developed serious problems with language, short-term memory, judgment, emotional regulation, and communication. He experienced seizures and headaches and struggled to understand the full extent of his own limitations.
By the time trial approached, Ramseās past medical expenses were nearly $840,000, while the projected lifetime cost of his future medical and care needs was approximately $12Ā million.
CrosleyĀ Law spent more than three years building the case. The team took more than 30 depositions, interviewed more than 40 additional witnesses, hired roughly a dozen experts, and conducted nine mock-jury focus groups.
The case settled for $20Ā million about a month before a multi-week jury trial was scheduled to begin.
Jury verdict Ā· Truck crash
$16+Ā million
Wrong-way 18-wheeler causes an āinvisibleā brain injury
Jerry was driving home on Loop 1604 after taking his adult son to the emergency room when he encountered an 18-wheeler traveling the wrong way.
Read the full story
The resulting head-on crash left Jerry with injuries that were not fully explained by his initial test results or outward appearance. His case eventually became an important example of why traumatic brain injuries can require deeper medical and legal investigation than more visible injuries.
CrosleyĀ Law dug into both the trucking companyās conduct and Jerryās medical condition. The investigation found that the commercial driver had falsified driving logs and violated federal motor carrier safety regulations. CrosleyĀ Law also sought out medical expertise capable of explaining the neurological problems Jerry continued to experience after the collision.
The case went to trial. After approximately two weeks of testimony and evidence, the jury awarded Jerry and his family more than $16Ā million in damages.
Jury verdict Ā· Brain injury
$11.5Ā million
Teenage trampoline park victim suffers permanent traumatic brain injury
A 16-year-old boy visited a Houston trampoline park with friends on the first day of summer. While using an eight-foot-tall trampoline feature, he unknowingly slid toward a large tear in the trampoline material that was hidden from his approach.
Read the full story
He fell through the opening and struck his head on the concrete floor below. The impact fractured his skull and caused bleeding in his brain. He also suffered a serious seizure shortly after the fall. As time passed, his family began noticing major changes in his personality and behavior, along with problems involving balance, coordination, memory, attention, headaches, ringing in his ears, and school performance.
CrosleyĀ Lawās investigation uncovered extensive evidence that the trampoline park knew about the hazardous condition. Security cameras captured the incident from multiple angles, and employee testimony established that the hole had existed since at least the previous day, that additional safety precautions could have been taken, and that the park lacked adequate written procedures for handling this kind of defect.
The jury found the trampoline park both negligent and grossly negligent and assigned it 100% of the fault. It awarded approximately $5.485Ā million in compensatory damages plus $6Ā million in punitive damages, for a total verdict of roughly $11.5Ā million.
Settlement Ā· Brain injury
$9Ā million
Pedestrian struck by delivery driver suffers TBI and devastating leg injuries
Zack was walking home from his job at a grocery store on a rainy evening when a delivery driver struck him from behind along a residential street.
Read the full story
His recovery was long and difficult. Zack underwent surgery to repair leg fractures, spent time in intensive care for a brain injury, and later completed a 20-day stay at an inpatient rehabilitation hospital. Once home, he still needed months of assistance with basic activities such as bathing and toileting. His right tibia eventually failed to heal properly, requiring another surgery roughly six months after the crash. Medical experts concluded that he would require lifelong monitoring and care because of his brain injury and leg damage.
CrosleyĀ Lawās investigation uncovered significant problems with the delivery company and its driver. Evidence indicated that the driver had been speeding, while the company had provided limited safe-driving training and failed to adequately address the driverās history of speeding. After initially disputing responsibility, the defense shifted tactics and argued that Zack himself was partly to blame because he was walking in the road at night and was not wearing reflective clothing. The company also argued that some of Zackās cognitive and psychological difficulties stemmed from his pre-existing autism rather than the traumatic brain injury.
CrosleyĀ Law responded with an intensive investigation. Tom Crosley and the team reviewed thousands of pages of documents and took 23 depositions, including testimony from corporate executives, the driver, accident reconstruction experts, and medical professionals. The firm also used focus groups and trial consulting to test the case and strengthen the presentation before mediation.
A few months before trial, the company and its insurers ultimately agreed to a $9Ā million settlement.
Settlement Ā· Wrongful death
$9Ā million
Grieving mother clears her daughterās name after a fatal truck crash
Amanda was a college freshman with plans for a bright future when a tractor-trailer struck her car in a Wilson County intersection and killed her. The truck driver told police that Amanda had run a red light, and with no surviving witness able to contradict him, the initial crash report blamed her for the collision.
Read the full story
Amandaās mother did not believe that explanation fit the daughter she knew. She hired CrosleyĀ Law, and the firm began a deeper investigation into what actually happened.
CrosleyĀ Law obtained the truck driverās employment records, dash-camera footage, and GPS-powered telematics data. That evidence changed the case completely. The dashcam showed that the truck driver had run the red light and did not brake until after the collision. After CrosleyĀ Law presented the evidence to investigators, the trooper amended the crash report and placed responsibility on the truck driver.
The investigation also uncovered troubling information about the trucking company. Its safety director had viewed the dashcam footage shortly after the wreck but did not disclose it while Amanda was being blamed. Records also showed that the driver had prior traffic convictions, multiple preventable accidents, and repeated safe driving coaching based on telematics data, yet the company continued allowing him to operate commercial vehicles.
Armed with crash evidence, expert analysis, detailed damages calculations, and extensive testimony about Amandaās life and potential, CrosleyĀ Law negotiated a $9Ā million settlement for the family.
Settlement Ā· Amputation
$6Ā million
Crane accident leads to below-the-knee amputation
Matt was working as a consultant at a West Texas oil and gas site when a large crane suddenly began moving while he was standing nearby. The crane crushed his feet and lower legs.
Read the full story
Matt spent 40 days in three hospitals and underwent four surgeries during that initial period. Over the next 20 months, he required four additional surgeries. Ultimately, doctors had to amputate his left leg below the knee. His medical bills approached half a million dollars, he could no longer work as he had before, and his wife had to return to work while also helping care for him.
The defendant attempted to blame Matt for being in the craneās path. However, CrosleyĀ Lawās investigation uncovered significant safety problems at the worksite. We gathered extensive testimony and worked with a crane expert, life care planner, economist, vocational rehabilitation specialist, neuropsychologist, and prosthetic specialist to document both the cause of the accident and Mattās long-term needs. The firmās analysis put his lifetime economic damages at more than $3Ā million.
The case ultimately resulted in a $6Ā million settlement.
Settlement Ā· Truck crash
$4.9Ā million
Traumatic brain injury after a semi-truck crash
Barbara was a retired U.S. Air Force Chief Master Sergeant who had built a second career teaching high school JROTC when a loaded tractor-trailer crashed into her pickup near Floresville.
Read the full story
The collision pushed her vehicle hundreds of feet and left her trapped inside. She suffered numerous fractures, lacerations, and other physical injuries, but some of the most devastating consequences involved her brain.
Doctors diagnosed Barbara with a traumatic brain injury. After the crash, she struggled with severe memory loss, attention problems, language difficulties, fatigue, depression, anxiety, impaired decision making, coordination problems, and personality changes. Her injuries prevented her from returning to the independent, highly accomplished life she had lived before the collision.
CrosleyĀ Law investigated the trucking company and driver, obtained electronic vehicle data, and worked with accident reconstruction experts. Evidence showed that the truck was traveling approximately 64 or 65 mph before the collision and that the driver did not brake until about one second before impact.
CrosleyĀ Law ultimately secured a $4.86Ā million settlement, helping ensure Barbara would have resources available as she continued living with permanent brain injuries.

Trial result Ā· Truck crash
$4Ā million
Trucking company ignored serious safety problems
Tim was driving on the interstate when an inattentive semi-truck driver struck his pickup.
Read the full story
He suffered severe injuries and eventually required neck surgery and a total hip replacement. Doctors also anticipated that he would require additional back surgeries.
CrosleyĀ Lawās investigation uncovered troubling evidence about both the driver and the trucking company. The driver had a history of unsafe cell phone use behind the wheel. Inspectors also found serious brake defects and placed the truck out of service.
Despite those problems, the trucking company continued operating the vehicle.
The case went to trial, where CrosleyĀ Law obtained a $4Ā million result.
Settlement Ā· Motorcycle crash
$3.75Ā million
Motorcycle rider initially blamed for a delivery truck crash
21-year-old Brandon was riding his motorcycle through a San Antonio industrial area when the driver of a commercial box truck turned left directly across his path.
Read the full story
The crash caused devastating injuries including broken bones, spinal fractures, lung injuries, internal bleeding, and a traumatic brain injury.
Making matters worse, the initial crash investigation incorrectly suggested Brandon was responsible. But CrosleyĀ Law did not simply accept that conclusion.
Our legal team and an accident reconstruction expert obtained and analyzed dash-camera footage from the delivery truck. The footage showed that Brandon had been clearly visible for several seconds before the impact. The truck driver later admitted that she did not see him before turning across his lane.
Additional medical evaluation documented a traumatic brain injury and permanent impairments. A life care plan also projected significant future medical needs.
The case ultimately settled for $3.75Ā million.
Settlement Ā· Truck crash
$3.4Ā million
Distracted truck driver caught on video
Michael was stopped in traffic when a heavy-duty flatbed truck crashed into the back of his vehicle at more than 30 mph. The impact caused skull fractures, a traumatic brain injury, and compression fractures in his spine.
The driver did not brake until approximately 0.3 seconds before impact.
Read the full story
Video evidence was alarming. A dashboard camera showed the truck driver with a phone balanced on his leg while looking away from the road and picking his nose rather than controlling his vehicle. Electronic control module data also showed that the driver did not brake until approximately 0.3 seconds before impact.
Michaelās economic damages were substantial, but his case involved much more than medical expenses. His brain injury caused ongoing headaches, anxiety, problems concentrating, sleep disturbances, balance issues, and loss of his sense of taste. It also interfered with work and activities he previously enjoyed.
CrosleyĀ Law identified $3Ā million in applicable insurance coverage and also discovered evidence of a vehicle defect that contributed to Michaelās injuries. An additional settlement from the vehicle manufacturer brought his total recovery to approximately $3.4Ā million.
Settlement Ā· Wrongful death
$2.5Ā million
Wrongful death caused by an unsafe highway merge
Daniel was killed after a tractor-trailer pulled onto the highway from the shoulder at night while traveling dramatically below highway speed.
Read the full story
The truck driver had stopped on the shoulder to relieve himself despite safer stopping options nearby. When he attempted to merge back into traffic, Daniel did not have enough time to avoid the truck.
The defense attempted to blame Daniel for the crash. CrosleyĀ Law investigated the collision and demonstrated why Daniel had no reasonable opportunity to anticipate the truckās unsafe maneuver.
His family ultimately received $2.5Ā million.
Jury verdict Ā· Neck injury
$1.87Ā million
Garbage truck crash dismissed as āminorā
In October 2022, Ellen was stopped in the drop-off area at her sonās Alamo Heights junior high when a roughly 50,000-pound garbage truck backed into her SUV.
Even the defense-retained spine surgeon agreed that the collision caused Ellenās previously asymptomatic condition to become symptomatic.
Read the full story
The trucking company eventually acknowledged that its driver was responsible for the collision. The real fight became whether the crash had actually caused Ellenās neck injury.
The defense emphasized the low-speed nature of the impact and modest property damage. A biomechanical expert calculated a change in velocity of roughly three miles per hour and argued that the forces involved were insufficient to cause Ellenās structural neck injury.
But Ellenās medical history showed that she had no prior neck symptoms. After the crash, she developed neck pain and neurological symptoms in her arm. An MRI showed a C5-6 condition involving spinal cord compression. She spent approximately 15 months pursuing conservative treatment before undergoing artificial-disc replacement surgery.
Remarkably, even the defense-retained spine surgeon agreed that the collision caused Ellenās previously asymptomatic condition to become symptomatic and led to the treatment and surgery that followed.
A Bexar County jury awarded Ellen approximately $1.87Ā million.
The anatomy of a big case
What makes some personal injury cases worth $1Ā million or more?
These above cases are very different, but large personal injury results tend to share several important characteristics.
01
Serious injuries and significant damages
02
Future needs resulting from injury
03
Enough insurance or assets to pay the claim
04
Aggravating conduct from the defendant
05
Serious investigation and preparation
Step 01
Serious injuries and significant damages
A personal injury settlement is supposed to compensate someone for losses caused by another partyās negligence.
Those damages may include past medical expenses, future medical care, lost wages, diminished earning capacity, physical pain, mental anguish, impairment, disfigurement, and other compensable losses. A person who suffers a minor injury and fully recovers within a short period generally will not have the same damages as someone who suffers permanent brain damage or requires multiple spinal surgeries.
That sounds obvious, but insurers sometimes focus heavily on medical bills while giving inadequate attention to how an injury affects the rest of someoneās life.
Step 02
Future needs resulting from injury
A serious case should not be evaluated only by looking backward.
Imagine someone has accumulated $200,000 in medical bills but will also need several future surgeries, ongoing rehabilitation, medications, home assistance, and decades of neurological care. Settling based solely on bills already incurred could leave that person responsible for enormous future expenses.
That is why high-value cases may require medical experts, life care planners, vocational experts, economists, neuropsychologists, and other specialists to evaluate what the injury will cost over the clientās lifetime.
Step 03
Enough insurance or assets to pay the claim
This is one of the harsh realities of personal injury law. If the person who caused your accident has only Texas minimum liability coverage and few personal assets, there may not be enough money available to compensate you fully.
That is why identifying every applicable insurance policy is important. Commercial trucking cases frequently involve larger liability policies. Businesses may have primary and excess coverage. Product manufacturers, property owners, employers, or other responsible parties may also create additional sources of recovery.
Your own uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage can sometimes become extremely important as well.
Step 04
Aggravating conduct from the defendant
Certain facts can make a case much more dangerous for an insurance company at trial.
A jury may react very differently to an unavoidable momentary mistake than it does to a commercial driver who is staring at a phone, a company that ignores dangerous defects in their products, or a business that repeatedly disregards its own safety procedures.
These facts donāt eliminate the need to prove damages, but they can affect how insurers evaluate their risk if the case goes before a jury. If a party knows they wonāt look good in court, they may be more likely to settle faster and for more.
Step 05
Serious investigation and preparation
Seven-figure cases almost always require deep research and Investigation.
That can mean preserving electronic evidence before it disappears, reviewing thousands of pages of medical and corporate records, taking depositions, finding the right experts, reconstructing the collision, documenting how a clientās life changed, and confronting defense experts who attempt to minimize those injuries.
At CrosleyĀ Law our goal is to be trial-ready in every case. Insurers know which lawyers regularly take difficult cases to trial and which ones rarely do. Knowing your personal injury attorney is willing to fightāand has a record of doing so successfullyācan make an insurer more willing to settle.
Evaluating your claim
How much is your personal injury case worth?
There is no quick and easy answer to this question.
A meaningful evaluation requires understanding your medical condition, your prognosis, how the injury affects your work and daily life, who caused the accident, what evidence exists, and what insurance coverage or other resources are available.

And sometimes the most important facts are initially obscured, missing, or outright wrong.
Brandon
$3.75Ā million
Brandonās initial crash report blamed him.
Ellen
$1.87Ā million
Ellenās vehicle showed relatively modest damage.
Barbara
$4.86Ā million
Barbaraās most devastating injury was not a fracture, but a permanent injury to her brain.
Thorough investigation that looked beneath the surface of the reports and into our clientsā lives changed the picture in each of these cases.
Seriously injured? Talk to CrosleyĀ Law
If you or a family member suffered a serious injury because of someone elseās negligence, CrosleyĀ Law can help you understand what your case may truly be worth.
We take the time to investigate what happened, understand how the injury has changed your life, identify every available source of compensation, and build the evidence necessary to pursue a fair result.
Contact CrosleyĀ Law today to request a free consultation.

The content provided here is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice on any subject.









