Minor Collision Causes Major Injuries: Betsy’s Story
At Crosley Law Firm, we handle a lot of personal injury cases involving car wrecks. In some instances, a devastating crash can result in severe injuries that ultimately heal, and the victim goes on to make a full recovery. The flip side is that we also see many collisions that appear to be minor but that lead to life-changing and lifelong complications for victims. This was one such case.
In January of 2013, 43-year-old Charles G. was driving a Volkswagen Passat sedan with his wife Betsy G., a real estate agent, in the front seat. They were stopped in traffic at a red light in a small town in Texas. Behind them, driving a Ford Ranger pickup for a delivery service, Adam R. rear-ended their car.
Although the impact was considered minor, Betsy G. suffered a concussion and was taken by ambulance to the emergency room. In the days, weeks, and months following the wreck, she suffered from many problems – physical, emotional, and mental. In the personal injury suit filed following the collision, she ultimately claimed a concussion; post-concussion syndrome; injury to the left hemisphere and frontal lobe; neurocognitive deficits; exacerbation of a preexisting seizure disorder; two separate episodes of status epilepticus, which is a medical emergency in which the brain is in a persistent state of seizure for more than five minutes; neck sprains and strains; and a torn left rotator cuff with impingement.
Despite suffering from a wide range of problems, the brain injuries and seizure disorder were the main focus of her damages claim. According to her neuropsychology expert, testing revealed neurocognitive deficits consistent with injury to the left hemisphere and the frontal lobe. This was particularly troublesome since Betsy had preexisting epilepsy that was controlled by medication with episodes occurring only about once every two years. After the accident, however, her epilepsy became markedly worse: she experienced an episode of status epilepticus only a few days after the crash and again a few months later.
In the wake of the crash, her injuries prevented her from driving and from working. Furthermore, she underwent physical therapy for her neck pain and required arthroscopic shoulder surgery.
The plaintiffs – Charles and Betsy G. – enlisted the help of Crosley Law Firm and sued Adam R. for negligently rear-ending them. They alleged that Adam R. was distracted by his cell phone at or near the time of the crash and that his driver’s license had expired approximately a week before the incident. They also sued the delivery service company, alleging that they had failed to enforce company policies relating to driver training and drivers’ licenses.
Naturally, the defense vehemently fought these accusations. For example, Adam R. denied that he was using his cell phone. He claimed that he stopped about 5 feet behind the plaintiffs and that, when he saw their brake lights turn off, he pressed the accelerator before realizing that they were still stopped.
Additionally, while Crosley Law Firm’s accident reconstruction expert estimated Adam R.s’ impact speed at 15 to 20 miles per hour, the defense accident reconstruction expert estimated the impact speed of Adam R. at 8 to 10 miles per hour. Because of this disparity (and citing that there was very little damage to either vehicle), the defense argued that the impact was very minor and did not cause Betsy’s injuries. The defense even went so far as to purchase exemplar vehicles and conduct a crash recreation, which supposedly confirmed that Adam R. was going only 8 miles per hour.
As for Betsy’s injuries, the defense argued that, if any, the injuries were preexisting and that, at most, the accident exacerbated her preexisting condition. For example, the defense psychiatric expert asserted that Betsy sustained only a mild concussion that should have resolved within a few weeks. The defense also strongly disputed Betsy’s claimed life care plan.
Despite the arguments of the defense, Crosley Law Firm expertly represented their clients. They extensively researched the circumstances surrounding the crash as well as the injuries inflicted upon Betsy. That research paid off. One example of this was when Crosley Law attorneys called an expert on mechanical forces who testified (in part) that one cannot reach conclusions about injuries based on property damage. This rendered much of the defense’s line of argument invalid.
Ultimately, in the suit, Betsy G. claimed approximately $40,000 in past lost earning capacity and loss of household services. Her medical bills were nearly $50,000. Her life care planning expert estimated her future medical expenses to be more than $300,000, all relating specifically to the head injury and seizure disorder.
The defense disputed whether the future medical expenses were related to her pre-existing seizure disorder or if they were instead, as the plaintiff claimed, related to an exacerbation of her condition due to the accident. Only time would tell if the treatments would be required. However, shortly before going to trial, the case settled for a fair amount that covered all of the damages claimed, and it was a resounding victory for both of Crosley Law Firm’s clients.
Related ArticlesView All Blog Articles
Cutting-Edge Tactics Result in a $16M Jury Award: Jerry M.’s StoryFeb 04, 2020
Jerry M. survived a horrific accident that could have been fatal. However, he was left with “invisible” injuries that, seemingly, no one could explain. This is the story of a man who desperately needed someone to dig deeper into his case and understand that something was seriously wrong, despite initial test results and outward appearances. […]
Crosley Law Uses Advanced Mediation Tactics to Settle CasesJul 18, 2019
At Crosley Law, we prepare every case as if it’s going to trial. However, we also understand the power of alternative dispute resolution (ADR), methods that help people avoid a trial and resolve their disputes out of court. We have a history of using aggressive legal techniques and excel at ADR methods like mediation. Keep […]
Six Months of Crosley CaresJul 02, 2019
With the start of the 2019 New Year, Crosley Law proudly launched the community service branch of our law firm, officially founding Crosley Cares. The brainchild of our Director of Happiness Ruthie Foultz, Crosley Cares was originally a client advocacy service offered because she recognized our clients needed support navigating the often-overwhelming processes involved in […]
Minor Collision Causes Major Injuries: Betsy’s Story
At Crosley Law Firm, we handle a lot of personal injury cases involving car wrecks. In some instances, a devastating crash can result in severe injuries that ultimately heal, and the victim goes on to make a full recovery. The flip side is that we also see many collisions that appear to be minor but […]
Complex Personal Injury Cases Require Dedicated, Resolute Attorneys
Occasionally at Crosley Law Firm, we acquire cases from other attorneys. Sometimes people make the deliberate choice to get new representation; other times, extenuating circumstances end up leading clients to our firm. In this case, our client’s former attorney became ill and could not keep up with his case load, and from the first day […]
One Unsafe Turn: How One Car Accident Changed Lives Forever
Stan H. and Dale A. were heading to a high school football game in Kerr County, Texas in the fall of 2012. Although both of them were in their 50s and had jobs (Stan was a sales representative, and Dale was a home inspector and real estate agent), they devoted their spare time to officiate […]
Crosley Law Firm Helps Retired Police Officer’s Family
Photo credit: daveynin / Foter / CC BY Since 2010, the Eagle Ford Shale region of southern Texas has become one of the most actively drilled areas for oil and gas in the nation. Because of all the development in the region, traffic has increased considerably, and there is now a significant commercial trucking presence […]
Crosley Law Firm Reaches Settlement for Hand Amputation Victims at Commercial Bakery
In 2014, Crosley Law Firm, PC reached a confidential settlement for an undisclosed amount against Lone Star Bakery in two separate hand amputation cases. Pete Gonzales and Erik Salgado, the plaintiffs, were injured in March and May of 2011, respectively. Two different machines at Lone Star Bakery caused the damage and resulted in severe injury […]
Settlement Reached in Lawsuit Against Driver Intoxicated on Hallucinogenic Mushrooms
This case involved what police called a “night of mayhem” in which a man ingested hallucinogenic mushrooms and got behind the wheel, causing several hit-and-run collisions. The plaintiffs of the case were represented by Tom Crosley and Charlie Gustin. The driver, Austin Hasten, rear-ended our clients in this case. Our clients were turning into the […]
3 ½ Years, 1 Yacht- Still No Settlement
Crosley Law Firm is known for taking on significant personal injury cases, many pertaining to auto accidents and traumatic brain injuries, all while providing the best possible representation for their clients. A case in Corpus Christi, Texas, deviates from their normal cases, not in terms of the service provided, but in terms of the client […]
Do you or a family member
need legal advice?
Crosley Law Firm, PC is a professional corporation of trial lawyers focused on representing individuals and families who have suffered serious personal injuries or wrongful death. If you’ve been injured, fill out the form for a free consultation, or call 210-LAW-3000.